|
With a 35% run up in the Nasdaq, the
first days of Spring have done a lot to lift our spirits
and hopes. While the wonderfully droll pundits yack
about "sucker’s rallys" and "dead cat’s
bounces," we’re much more optimistic. Why? Because
we think our old friend Dr. Al might have finally passed
through the Looking Glass and come to grasp the counter-intuitive
realities of a world where supply, not demand
dominates the global economy.
In this
Lewis Carrollesque world of "deflation," what
once was "good" could be "bad" (tax
cuts), and once unthinkable (intentional inflation),
a preventative cure. So, if we piqued your curiosity,
follow us into the Byzantine rabbit warren of investing
in a deflationary world!
Following
the dot.bombing of Wall Street in March, we’ve emerged
from our fall-out shelters. The Good News? A vital signs
check of our Mega-Trends continues to point towards
prosperity. Both the spread of Democracy and Capitalism
continue to promise expanding new markets and opportunities.
Clearly the U.S. of A. remains the epicenter of innovation,
from which multiple waves of change are washing over
the economies of the world. Last, but not least, our
economy remains healthy albeit with a slowdown in productivity
gains and just enough growth to avoid the dreaded "R"
word of Recession.
Make
no mistake about it:
The flood of innovations in areas such as Bio-tech,
Nano-tech, Alternative Energy, Telecom and a host of
other areas has not slowed down simply because the stock
market stubbed it’s toe. This rate of change is real
and is accelerating. And as our motto says: "Innovation
equals Opportunity!"
So why the
market’s malaise? We’ve often said our "operating
system" of DOS Capitalism is almost idiot proof
when left to its own devices. The greatest risk comes
in the form of "operator error" when political
intervention kluges up the system. The recent market
episode is the aftermath of well intentioned Dr. Al
tightening interest rates last summer to inoculate us
from non existent inflation.
If the good
doctor had sought our second opinion, he’d have known
"deflation" not "inflation"
is the real threat. In the mumbo-jumbo of this dismal
science, this is a world where "supply"
dominates "demand."
Accepting
this seemingly simple conceptual shift sets off a ripple
effect which challenges our most basic (and important)
investment decision rules. At times it’s like we’ve
passed through Lewis Carroll’s "Looking Glass"
into an economic world where "up" is "down"
and "good" is "bad." So stick with
us for a spot of tea, crumpets, and a Mad Hatter’s explanation
of why job layoffs and a weaker dollar are "good"
and tax cuts and a strong dollar might be "bad"
right now or at least too much of a good thing..
Over our
past nine issues we have been constructing a framework
of how to invest in a world where "supply"
dominates and our old rules don’t seem to work quite
as well. Numbering now over 35 "Thoughts For The
New Age," these have been collected into a single
report and are now available on the web through either
Barnes & Noble at bn.com
or at knexa.com
under the keyword "Strudwick".
Here are
our latest thoughts and musings to challenge your thinking
on investing in a rapidly changing world:
Thought
#34. In the topsey turvey world of Global Deflation,
The Republican’s cure-all prescription of Domestic Tax
Cuts is not the correct medicine. Instead, a small dose
of inflation by increasing monetary supply might be
the vaccine we need to ward off the very ugly deflationary
spiral virus caused by a global supply-demand imbalance.
Before the
Red Queen screams "Off with Your Head" for
uttering this heresy, please understand we remain card
carrying members of Tax Haters Unanimous. But…
tax cuts designed to "revitalize" an already
strong domestic economy and stimulate
consumer demand are not the solution to a long-term
global problem. This is a band-aid solution,
which neglects the chronic underlying condition.
With "Shop
Until You Drop" having replaced "E
Pluribus Unum" as our national motto, it’s
very clear the root of our problem is not the U.S consumer’s
failure to hold up our end of the spending side of the
equation. Our negative national savings rate is proof
of that.
Instead,
we should focus on the global supply side
of the equation. Since the Fall of Communism, NAFTA,
GATT and the global telecom, Net and IT revolutions,
manufacturing capacity worldwide has increased faster
than the newly opened markets of China, Russia, and
India were able to grow new "consumers." Unfortunately,
these billions of people don’t qualify as western style
consumers until there is an appetite for, and money
to spend on middle class "necessities." Do
you need a Palm Pilot in Tibet?
Growing
demand organically is a painfully slow
process requiring years to convert workers into consumers.
You upgrade from rice to chicken before trading in the
wok for the microwave.
When viewed
through this prism, there are only two remedies
to bring supply and demand back into balance long-term.
Either decrease global supply by shutting
down plants (painful for the U.S investors who financed
these plants with the double negative of also stunting
the growth of new non-U.S. consumers). Currently the
domestic plant closings and layoffs are part of this
phenomena. This is "good" because these resources
will be reallocated into other industries, helping to
decrease the excess capacity.
Or, increase
demand from consumers outside of the United States.
Clearly a better alternative than mothballing
plants, but still a slow process. One way to speed up
this process is to make U.S. goods cheaper by lowering
the value of the dollar. Deface the greenback?! Heresy!
you say, but what if the Buck has gotten grossly overvalued?
Thought
#35. Honey, pack dem bags, we’re going to Europe! Relative
to other currencies, the Dollar is now clearly too strong.
Look for continued interest rate cuts to help drive
down the value of the greenback. Investment themes that
favor a moderately falling dollar and falling interest
rates will excel. These include zero coupon bonds, commodities,
and closed end country funds.
Each year
the Economist publishes it’s Big Mac Index revealing
the price of two all beef paddies on a sesame seed bun
in about 30 countries around the world. America’s culinary
contribution to the world is now cheaper in 27 of those
countries than here in the States. In Australia, New
Zealand, Brazil, and Hong Kong a Big Mac costs 40% less
than in the States. That’s almost twice the calories
and fat grams per buck without super-sizing!
This bit
of burger-nomics gives us a valuable clue
as to what’s going on right now. With the dollar too
dear, Dr. Al is cutting interest rates not to
stimulate the economy, but rather to drive down
the Buck. Look for as much as 150 to 200 basis points
of additional cuts from here. Long maturity zero-coupon
bonds are a way to play (American
Century Target Maturity 2020 fund –8.79% YTD). Second,
equities with currency risk should do well as the dollar
falls. Closed-end country funds are a good way to play
this. Our positions in funds like Chile
(NYSE, CH – up 6.19% YTD), Brazil
(NYSE, BRZ –Down 2.98%) and Latin
America Discovery (NYSE, LDF up 6.6%) have done
well in this environment.
Action
Idea: If you owe your wife a trip abroad, those shoes
in Paris won’t get any cheaper than this.
Thought
#36. Japan is Dr. Al’s monetary laboratory of Dr. No
showing us how not to deal with deflation and the price
of a missed diagnosis. A 10-year bear market with more
pain to come is the price paid for trying to cure deflation
by stimulating domestic demand.
After 10
years of denial and 11 prime ministers in 13 years,
Japan acknowledged last month that it was stuck in a
deflationary spiral. Having gone from being the world’s
greatest lender to it’s greatest debtor, it is painfully
clear massive government spending (fiscal policy) is
a virtually powerless tool to break a deflationary spiral
once it sets in. Stimulating domestic demand does not
work because it doesn’t resolve the underlying supply
glut. When consumers recognize prices are falling, they
cut consumption waiting for future price
drops. After the most recent shuffling of the deck chairs
on the S.S. Sinking Sun, serious problems
remain on the horizon with little time to shift course.
Look for a major economic debacle next Fall when
the latest
team of reformers fail to avert a banking crisis. Ignore
the advice of bottom fishing pundits saying
" this time it’s different." It’s not. With
some "mad money" you can short Japan
using the WEBS Japan. (AMEX- WEJ) Continue to avoid
the Emerging Tech Tiger theme as a regional banking
crisis could torpedo them.
Thought
#37. Just as Inflation brings relief to borrowers, Deflation
will grind them into dust because they must repay in
higher valued dollars. Before stoking the domestic demand
engine (and increasing consumer debt), Dr. Al needs
to restore the balance between borrowers and lenders.
Here’s why:
Our current high "real interest" rates have
created an imbalance between borrowers and lenders.
Over the last 200 years, people lending money to the
government have been paid 3% over the rate of inflation.
So a 6% bond yield would imply a 3% inflation rate and
a 3% "real rate" of return to the lender.
But what if we don’t actually have inflation, and prices
are flat or falling? This would imply
a "real" rate of return of 6% or greater!
In other words, it’s actually twice as expensive to
borrow as it has been historically. For large companies,
high real interest rates slows down economic expansion
as "the cost of capital" becomes too high
and they opt instead to grow by only reinvesting profits.
From the
little guy’s perspective, these colossal "real"
interest rate spreads will slowly grind borrowers into
dust as debt payments must be made in more expensive
dollars. Pity the consumer with the perpetual balance
on the credit card, he’s getting pulverized and doesn’t
even know it.
Dr. Al needs
to restore this crucial balance between creditors and
debtors. Increasing the liquidity (money
supply) in the markets will go a long way in this direction.
In other words, a small dose of inflation to bring down
the value of the dollar is a vaccine against a more
virulent form of deflation. Our
advice here: aggressively decrease personal debt and
pay cash whenever possible. Defer unnecessary
purchases because with deflation the prices are cheaper
next month. When Dell and Compaq are locked in a price
war, do you buy today, or wait until next month for
a better deal?
Having jumped
down the rabbit hole of this upside down world caused
by a supply dominated economy, let’s now sit down for
tea with the Mad Hatter and discuss the even more confounding
logic of why now might be a great time
to invest in the markets.
Let’s start
first with a little parsing of terms and differentiate
between "The Economy" and "The
Market." Though closely related, each moves
in it’s own unique rhythmic cycle. Assuming these two
gyrating dancers are joined at the hip can be a very
expensive mistake. Instead, The Market tends to swirl
around The Economy. The leaps and dips of the "Markets"
tend to predict the future direction of the "economy,"
which we refer to as a business cycle.
A classic
cycle has 4 distinct phases,
(recovery,
expansion, overheating, and contraction). What is surprising
is that 90% of the total market action is
concentrated in just two of the sectors. Returning to
our Mad Hatter logic, the most dangerous time to be
in the Markets is not when the Economy
is contracting, but rather when it is still expanding
but overheating. This typically causes the Fed to increase
rates, thereby starting the contraction phase. Stocks
lose an average of 17%, the Overheating Period (when
corporate profits are still expanding) versus 3% in
the contraction phase accounting for 85% of aggregate
downside risk in the market.
The
Best Time For Different Investments
|
GDP
Growth Negative & Falling
|
Bonds
|
|
GDP
Growth Negative but Improving
|
Stocks
|
|
Growth
Positive & Improving
|
Commodities
|
|
Growth
Positive But Slowing
|
Cash
|
To further
confound common sense, stocks generally have their greatest
upside starting about 6 months before
the trough of an economic cycle while the economy is
still contracting! Why? Because the markets are predictive
not reactive. This is when the Fed starts to inject
liquidity into the markets to prime the economic engine.
Historically, this is the #1 Fat Time
to buy stocks. Here’s a stat to chew on: In a typical
3 year stock market rally, over 50% of the entire Bull
Market rally is captured in this initial first 6 months
with average returns of 36%!
O.K., so
for the proverbial $64,000 question: Where are we in
this cycle? First, let’s clear some debris out of the
way here. Despite the NASDAQ having dropped 60% in 12
months (before the recent rally), the Economy has never
"officially" dipped into "recession"
which requires six months of "negative growth."
We’ve simply had a sharp contraction in our
(still) positive growth rate.
Even with
the new math, 1% growth doesn’t qualify for the start
of a recession. For trend line plotters, the very recent
first quarter ‘01 GNP numbers have come in at 2%. How
can we have a recession when the last two quarters have
had positive economic growth?
Through
our looking glass, we see another 3 to 6 months of "profit
warnings and layoffs" coming from the tech sector
already baked into Dr. Al’s crumpets. But the liquidity
numbers are already increasing rapidly, telling us a
remedy is in the making. Our conclusion is we’re
likely in the very early stages of the sweet spot stock
market rally. The 60% decline in the NASDAQ
was predicting a recession that never appeared. The
35% NASDAQ rally is the market consensus that Al’s rate
cuts and liquidity increases are the right medicine.
The
greatest risk is waiting
on the sidelines waiting for better visibility in the
Fall. Six months from now 50% of the rally will likely
be over. We would rather be fully invested and dollar
cost averaging into our positions now, then pulling
chips
off the
table.
But aren’t
stocks still expensive at 20x earnings? Perhaps in an
absolute sense, but as our Uncle Albert E. used to say
"all things are relative." When
you look at the inverse of the P/E ratio (known as the
"earnings yield"), a P/E of 20 equates to
an earning yield of 5%. Relative to its historic relationship
with government bonds, this is a reasonable price to
pay for stocks. Last time we looked, bond interest rates
were dropping with the consensus of the curb watchers
agreeing more cuts were on the way.
We
want to hear from You!
If you’d
like to find out more about our wealth strategies such
as tax sheltered investment strategies for both individuals
and companies please give us a call. In addition, we
manage investment portfolios, and also help companies
review option on retirement plans, life insurance. Our
number is (410) 727-6444. We’ll be happy to discuss
your objectives as well as explore your options.
To close
out we thought we’d bring you up to date on several
of the stocks that we’ve suggested for consideration
in your portfolio.
"A
question that sometimes drives me hazy
Am
I or are the others crazy."
----
Albert Einstein
Special
Announcement:
Contact
us about our new "Omni-Asset IRA" accounts.
If you want to use the trapped liquidity of your IRA
to invest in non-traditional such as real estate, mortgages
or private companies, we might have a terrific solution
for you.
Please
call (410) 727-6444 or toll free at 1(866) 4-NOLOAD.
Strudwick
Wealth Strategies
12 East Eager Street * Baltimore, Maryland 21202
Tel. 410. 727. 6444 * invest@noload.com
|